Buck Privates: Gwahaniaeth rhwng fersiynau
Cynnwys wedi'i ddileu Cynnwys wedi'i ychwanegu
Llinell 37:
Yn ôl Lubin "''the studio was a little uncertain about how they were going to be accepted. But at the first preview the audience just died. Buck Privates was a very, very funny show. And, actually, I must say it was very little credit to the director. It consisted mainly of fabulous gags that these two wonderful guys knew from years and years of being in burlesque''."<ref name="kings" /> Yn dilyn llwyddiant y ffilm, gofynnodd y stiwdio i Lubin ffilmio, ''Oh, Charlie!'' a ddaeth yn ''Hold That Ghost'' yn hwyrach ymlaen yn y broses.
Derbyniodd y ffilm adolygiadau cadarnhaol. Yn ôl Theodore Strauss o ''The New York Times'' "''an hour and a half of uproarious monkeyshines. Army humor isn't apt to be subtle and neither are Abbott and Costello. Their antics have as much innuendo as a 1,000-pound bomb but nearly as much explosive force.''" <ref>{{cite web |url=https://www.nytimes.com/movie/review?res=940DE3D7123DE33BBC4C52DFB466838A659EDE |title=Movie Reviews - Buck Privates |last=Strauss |first=Theodore |date=February 14, 1941 |website=[[The New York Times]] |publisher= |accessdate=December 14, 2015 }}</ref>
Ysgrifennodd ''Variety'' , "''Geared at a zippy pace, and providing lusty and enthusiastic comedy of the broadest slapstick, Buck Privates is a hilarious laugh concoction that will click solidly in the general runs for profitable biz''." <ref>{{cite magazine |last= |first= |date=February 5, 1941 |title=Buck Privates |url= |magazine=[[Variety (magazine)|Variety]] |location=New York |publisher=Variety, Inc. |page=12 |accessdate= }}</ref>
''Film Daily'' - "''If ever a 'sleeper' appeared out of Hollywood, this is it ... the attraction is a grand, madcap musical which packs a whale of a wallop for the general public liking laughs galore on the frankly slapstick side''."<ref>{{cite journal |last= |first= |date=February 3, 1941 |title=Reviews of New Films |url= |journal=[[Film Daily]] |location=New York |publisher=Wid's Films and Film Folk, Inc. |page=9 |accessdate= }}</ref>
''Harrison's Reports'' - "''A good comedy for the masses ... Abbott and Costello definitely establish themselves as a comedy team that should win wide popularity."''<ref>{{cite journal |last= |first= |date=December xx, 1941 |title='Buck Privates' with Bud Abbott, Lou Costello, Lee Bowman and Alan Curtis |url= |journal=[[Harrison's Reports]] |location= |publisher= |page=27 |accessdate= }}</ref>
''Diabolique'' magazine - "''It’s become fashionable in later years among Abbott and Costello aficionados to decry Buck Privates – purists complain about all those Andrews Sisters numbers and the time devoted to a “straight” love triangle. Hold That Ghost (1941) and especially Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein (1948) are more highly regarded by buffs. But I think it’s terrific – in part because of that love triangle (which is very well acted) and the Andrews Sisters, but also because Abbott and Costello were rarely so energetic. They’re in top form with brilliant routines, and Lubin treats it all with the perfect light touch''." <ref>{{Cite magazine|magazine=Diabolique Magazine|first=Stephen|last=Vagg|url=https://diaboliquemagazine.com/the-cinema-of-arthur-lubin/|date=14 September 2019|title=The Cinema of Arthur Lubin}}</ref>
== Gwobrau ==
| |||